Real Madrid vs FC Barcelona: A Comparative Analysis of Fan Impact on Business Success and Asset Management

Abstract

This paper highlights the critical role of fan engagement in shaping the business success and asset management strategies of two of the world’s most successful football clubs Real Madrid and FC Barcelona.Through a comparative analysis, the study explorers how fan loyalty, cultural significance, and global outreach influence the financial performance and long-term strategic decisions of each club.By inspecting key areas such as revenue generation, brand value, merchandise sales, and media rights, the research highlights how fan-driven factors contribute to the club’s financial sustainability and their approach to managing valuable assets and players.the research also identifies differences in the club’s business models, particularly in terms of leveraging fan loyalty for global expansion and asset optimization.

History of Real Madrid & FC Barcelona

Real Madrid and FC Barcelona are one of the biggest and fiercest sports rivalries in the world. The rich history and heritage of both clubs influence their fan bases. The “El Clásico” averages a viewership of more than 660 million people worldwide, and as of November  2024, Real Madrid has won 105 of the matches compared to FC Barcelona’s 101 (with 52 draws; Gifford, 2024). 

Real Madrid was founded in 1902 as The Madrid Football club were granted the honorary title “real” by King Alfonso XII in 1920 in addition to the crown being added to their crest. Their history consists of gifted players like Ferenc Puskás, Alfredo Di Stéfano, Paco Gento, Hector Rial, Miguel Muñoz, and Cristiano Ronaldo. Real Madrid also holds the record for winning the most number of champions league titles (15). Their rival, FC Barcelona, was founded in 1899 by businessman Joan Gamper. The club’s first trophy was the Copa Macaya (which they won in 1902), and they won the Copa del Rey in 1910. Barcelona have won 31 Copa del Rey, the highest number for any team. Some of the legendary players that played for FC Barcelona are Johan Cruyff, Diego Maradona, Luis figo, Rivaldo, Ronaldinho, Samuel Eto’o, Xavi and most notably, Lionel Messi (Gifford, 2024). 

The rivalry between Real Madrid and FC Barcelona transcends the football pitch, illustrating how fan involvement significantly influences business organization and asset management strategies, as both clubs leverage their passionate supporter bases to drive revenue, enhance brand loyalty, and navigate the complexities of modern sports economics in a competitive landscape.

Fandom & Rivalry in Sport

The International Fan

In the context of Pu and James’s (2016) study, a fan is defined as an individual who shows a strong emotional attachment and identification with a sports team, having a sense of belonging and community with other supporters. Fans connect with their teams through multiple means, including following games, participating in discussions, and consuming related media, regardless of their geographical proximity to the team. Emotion and psychology link the fan to a felt reality, signifying devotion and pride. A local fan is one who resides within a proximal distance to the location of the team, and often, he has direct access to games, events, and other activities associated with the team. It makes it more real to relate to the team.

An international fan, on the other hand, is one who supports a team coming from a very distant place, often outside of one’s country. International fans communicate with their team more through media, social networks, and merchandise by relying on digital means, though not in the same direct ways as local fans. This study presents distinct motivations and experiences of fans.

Fans are the most significant predictor of whether a team can be successful, as huge revenues will be collected at the turnstiles selling tickets, in merchandise such as clothing and souvenirs, and in food and other concession sales from the additional people who have attended games. The franchise will always have more supporters to pay for the higher revenue for the short and long-term stability if it can attract more fans. Loyal fans also help in the creation of brand strength within the team. This is because their loyalty makes the team image even more attractive for sponsors and partners, increasing their appeal. Such loyalty can be seen as stability and continuity. 

Fans also impact a team’s success by the support they provide; a noisy, boisterous crowd can create a charged game-day atmosphere that may affect player performance. Home court is improved with a home crowd for psychological advantage to players and as an intimidating setting to visiting opponents. Fans also help create a shared community and identity that might revolve around the team.

In this context, identification can create an ethos of support where the fans mobilize both when the going is good as well as when it’s tough to rally around the team to motivate both players and staff. Social media is a phenomenon of today’s world, though it is beyond the confines of the arena for contemporary fan engagement. By the power of social media, it enables fans to voice their support and content, thus connecting with other fans worldwide, multiplying their reach and influence of the team. This online presence can attract new fans as well as sustain fans’ interest from a distance. Fans provide the team with necessary feedback, which can be used to improve and become better. It could be performance critiques or even marketing strategy feedback. The possibility of loyalty and satisfaction is much higher when a team listens to their fans and adapts

The study shows light on how international NBA fans are greatly affected and influenced by media coverage, especially through television broadcasts,social media and online platforms. This detection is also relevant for Real Madrid, who have one the largest and diverse international fan bases in the world. The club heavily invests in digital media which consists of streaming matches,and constantly creating content across platforms like YouTube and other official social media apps. The club’s online presence much like the NBA’s allows international fans to access exclusive player content, engage in fan communities and connect with other international fans despite geographical barriers through social media.

One of the key findings from Pu and James (2016) is that international NBA fans create strong psychological connections with players and teams, despite the geographical distance. Likewise, Real Madrid fans around the globe share an emotional bond with the club, to a great extent driven by the history, its legendary players (Alfredo Di stefano, David Beckam, Zinedine Zidane ,Cristiano Ronaldo, Sergio Ramos, Ferenc Puskas) and iconic status of the club. Real Madrid’s brand is constructed around a sense of prestige, success,and glamor, which appeals to fans beyond the boundaries of Spain. Similar to the NBA, the clubs exploit the global presence of their players which allows fans from different cultures and countries to emotionally connect with the team regardless of where they are located.

The study  also highlights how international fans often connect with the league or team due to their cultural or personal views. With respect to Real Madrid, this is especially relevant when considering the club’s ability to attract diverse fan bases from every part of the world. For example, fans from Latin America, the Middle East, and Asia in many instances feel a sense of cultural affinity with Real Madrid, through shared language, similar values of ambition and excellence, or admiration for the club’s international players. The club’s outreach strategy also aligns with this by not only focusing on performance on the pitch but also by leveraging cultural touchpoint,which also includes its association with well known brands like Adidas, tailoring marketing content to various regional tastes and preferences.

For international NBA fans, entertainment and social connection are key motivations as mentioned in the study. Real Madrid’s engagement with their international fans is based on creating entertainment beyond the pitch,which includes behind-the-scenes content,interviews with the players,and fan events worldwide. The club’s social media campaigns encourage the audience to interact with the team and other fans through virtual engagement, fan clubs, and events, which creates a sense of community. This idea matches directly with the motivations of distant NBA fans, who engage with the teams not only for the thrill of the sport but also want to feel included in a global social network of fans.

The NBA has used its image as a global sporting brand to build a fan base through global branding, Real Madrid has paved the way for them to be internationally recognized as a symbol of football excellence. The club reinforces their global brand by entering into strategic global partnerships building their audience from around the world. The club’s ‘Los Blancos’ brand, combined with the club’s success in both domestic and international competitions, makes it an attractive option for fans worldwide who perceive the club as not just a football team but as a cultural and global icon.

International NBA fans form strong psychological bonds because they feel a sense of belonging to a larger community. Real Madrid have created a similar community for their international fans through fan interaction and participation on their global platforms, by organizing international tours and engaging in local and international events, they foster a sense of belonging for fans no matter where they live.

Rivalry

Luís Figo’s transfer from F.C. Barcelona to Real Madrid in 2000 was perhaps among the most controversial deals ever. The Portuguese winger was adored in Barcelona, having joined in 1995 and quickly won the hearts of fans. However, in a shocking turn of events, he joined their arch-rivals Real Madrid for an astounding release clause of €60 million, arguably making him the most expensive player in the market at that moment. This move invoked a brutal backlash from the Barcelona fans, who ultimately termed it betrayal; sporadically giving rise to violent confrontations, one in which Figo was hit by a barrage of items and had a pig’s head tossed at him during his first return to Camp Nou. The transfer was not only an intensifying drill for this historic rivalry but also initiated the period of “Galácticos” for Real Madrid, fusing with Figo’s legacy of a player who rose from the allegiances of football for good or for evil.

Real Madrid is very famous for its “Galácticos” policy. Galactico is the spanish word for ‘galactic’ and is used to describe footballers who are deemed to be superstars or have levels of talent that equal the galaxies or are out of the world. The club targets marquee players to create a star-studded lineup. This approach led to high-profile signings, like Cristiano Ronaldo in 2009 and Eden Hazard in 2019; all of whom at crucial points in the competitive cycle as well- for instance immediately after having major success. The club tends to ‘let go’ players when they fail to meet its present needs or whose game becomes poor with significant churn. As an example, they sold Cristiano Ronaldo in 2018; they were then able to restock their team and regroup from the shock loss of superstar status (Kelly, 2023). Whereas FC Barcelona have mainly purchased young prospects who have potential, such as Frenkie de Jong in 2019. That has been the philosophy of building stars out of the youth  reports that Barcelona is slow to sell its players, mainly showing loyalty to the veterans, as was the case with Lionel Messi, until financial issues made it impossible to continue to do so in 2021. 

This shift was massive because they were not able to design alternatives for the well-known names (attacking football, 2024). Real Madrid has followed the policy of effective signing. Through this process, it reschedules and rejuvenates the team in the playing field to emerge victorious in prominent titles in the short-term cycle, such as the two UEFA Champion League titles earned in 2014 and 2018. It facilitates its transition very rapidly and allows it to attain short-term victories. Barcelona has followed a sustainable model. It spends in creating human assets in the long-term. However, their recent performances, especially after losing the services of Messi, seem to have exposed some of its weaknesses in the strategy devised. They were also beset by severe financial challenges and did not have instantaneous star power, making their recent performances not that brilliant.

Real Madrid’s acquisitions did not stop their string of successes in both domestic as well as European competitions whereas their releases like Ronaldo helped them rebuild effectively. The first place Barcelona succeeded was through emphasis on youth development. Success after that has been tainted with a failure to transition fast when players are lost, for instance, in La Liga and the Champions League. Real Madrid and FC Barcelona can have vastly contrasting philosophies about gaining and releasing their players that may reflect wider strategic ambitions. Real Madrid is bent on winning now through power houses whereas Barcelona would go for gradual development. That has largely dictated the recent few years’ course, achievements, and difficulties.

The organizational structure of both the teams are unique and not common in sports teams around the world.  In the case of Real Madrid, they are owned by the members or ‘socios’ as they call them, all the business decisions and ownership is in the hands of the members. The members vote for the President and the Board of Directors. According to their 2014 annual report, there are approximately 91000 ‘socios’ who pay on an average 123 euros per year as membership fees. To make the presidential election process or the Board of Directors election process easier the ‘socios’ hold an election to select and form a Member Assembly, which consists of 2000 members and run a four-year term. The main responsibilities of the Membership Assembly consist of framing and approving the club’s budget for the season, as well as authorizing the club to borrow money if needed. The Membership Assembly also has the authority to discipline the president of the club (Bonn, 2022).

With FC Barcelona their members are called ‘soci’. There are reportedly around 140,000 ‘soci’ who pay an annual fee of 150 euros. They are represented by a group of members who come together with the board to vote on major decisions. Adult members are allowed to vote in the presidential elections and each president serves a four-year term. The ‘soci’ must approve all the club’s financial and sporting decisions before they can pass into the club statute (Pettigrove, 2015).

Business Outcomes & Organization

Revenue & Sponsorship

Real Madrid has three streams of revenue mainly the commercial revenues, broadcasting revenues and ticketing revenues. The total revenue of the ‘los blancos’ in 23/24 shows a 27% jump compared to the 22/23 figures and 42% increase from their 18/19 figures which was their previous highest. The match day and commercial revenue streams have contributed mainly. With reference to broadcasting the revenues received from La Liga in 23/24 are lower than the revenues received in 22/23 season. With the recent renovations in the Santiago Bernabéu, the completely revamped stadium will generate around 400 million euros from over 200 events per year, this also includes the NFL’s inaugural game in Spain(Garcia, 2024). Likewise, the commercial revenue which includes sponsorship deals, the most notable ones being kit partners Adidas, sleeve sponsors HP, and telecom partnership with Orange including 5G integration at the stadium (Leveridge, 2024).

The total revenue of FC Barcelona grew by around 25% in 22/23 which is reported to be around 859 million euros. Most of its income generated is from commercial sales during the 22/23 season (Sim, 2023). Sponsorship deals include Nike as their kit partner, Japanese e-commerce company Rakuten, and the Turkish home appliances company Reko. The revenue from sponsorship deals amount to a combined 247 million euros (Dalleres, 2021).  The revenue expected from the stadium after renovations is projected to be around 350 million euros. Spotify is also one of the main sponsors, with a sponsorship deal worth around 280 million euros. From LaLiga reports it is confirmed that FC Barcelona also received 800 million euro from sale of their broadcasting rights to Sixth Street and from the proposed sale of shares in the club’s media subsidiary (Dixon, 2022).

Both the Spanish giants have had a huge impact on the Spanish economy. As of 2019 both of their combined revenue stands at 0.12% of Spain’s GDP, together reaching a combined revenue of 1.6 billion euros as of 2019. If player transfers revenues were also considered the economic impact on the economy would be 0.14% which is 1.8 billion euros. Real Madrid ended the 2018-2019 season with their operating revenues totaling 757 million euros. The growth which the club has projected is impressive. In 2003, it had a turnover of 193 million euros, in 2008 the turnover was over 351 million euros and a decade later they generated 514 million euros. After 2018, their turnover has exceeded 700 million euros in revenue. In 2019, the club’s wages expenditure exceeded 355 million euros or 47% of their operating revenues. Their highest salary level was in 2017 which totaled 377 million euros or 56% of their revenues. Over the past decade, Real Madrid have invested 911 million euros in player acquisition. Despite having heavy investment and high wage spending, Real Madrid closed every year with net profits. In the past few years, they have amassed over 347 million euros in net profits. 

In the case of FC Barcelona, their operating revenues in the 2018-19 season was a total 837 million euros, compared to the 690 million euros they made from the previous season with a revenue growth of 21% in 2019. FC Barcelona grew more compared to Real Madrid. In 2003, they made 123 million euros. Five years later it surpassed 290 million and after a decade it reached 483 million euros. Barça’s wages expenditure in 2019 was 426 million euros or 51% of their operating revenue. Over the last decade Barça have invested 868 million in player acquisition. Although on the other hand they accumulated 113 million euros in net profits, which is significantly lower than their rivals (Somoggi, 2019).

Real Madrid’s Valdebebas academy complex consists of 11 football pitches including the Alfredo Di Stefano stadium and the Santiago Bernabeu. The club’s youth development academy also known as ‘La Fabrica’ hosts 364 players in total across female and male sections. There are a total of 55 players in the La Liga that have passed through the ‘La Fabrica’. They generate an income of 39 million euros from the academy. The income from youth player sales for the club has generated 395 million euros since 2009 (de Juan,Quaile, 2023). During the summer transfer window of 2022, Real Madrid made 15 million euros with the departure of Borja Mayoral, Miguel Gutierrez, and Victor Chust. Although only a few players make it to the first team like Dani Carvajal, Nacho Fernandez, and Lucas Vazquez other team players like Vinicius Junior, Rodrygo, Federico Valverde and Mariano Diaz all joined as youngsters and appeared for the Real Madrid Castilla the club’s reserve team. La Fabrica’s origins date back to the 1950s, started by the club’s most famous president Santiago Bernabeu. The academy aims to create what they call a ‘global’ player. The academy encourages their players to adapt a flexible style of football and to not develop a style that is too fixed (Rai,2023). The club made 95 million euros in the 2020 summer transfer window from home grown academy player sales (Matt, 2020).

FC Barcelona’s ‘La Masia’ which is Catalan for ‘the farmhouse’. The original building was an ancient farmstead which was built in 1702 and the club’s Camp Nou stadium was built in 1957 next to the ‘La Masia’. Some of the greatest players who came out of the academy are Pep Guardiola, Carles Puyol, Victor Valdes, Andres Inieta, Xavi, and most notably Lionel Messi (Kelly, 2023). In 2024 FC Barcelona generated an income of 189 million euros from home grown player sales. The market value of the starting eleven is worth approximately around 304 million euros and more than 220 million euros or 72% of that value comes from La Masia players (Gabriele, 2022). Unlike Real Madrid (who are focused on acquiring young talented players), La Masia’ and FC Barcelona are dedicated to developing in-house talent. 

The Financial Situation of Barcelona

For more than a decade, FC Barcelona was one of the most formidable and revered football clubs in the world. The famous blue and maroon stripes conveyed a sense of sporting excellence and supreme domination. The iconic organization is in major debts; an ever increasing wage bill and an underperforming playing 11. Between 2003 and 2010 Barcelona’s revenue grew from 123 million euros to 387 million euros, an increase of 215%. This growth continued reaching an all-time high of 814 million euros in 2019 (Gabriele, 2022). The COVID-19 pandemic was also a problem for the club with players continuing to draw salaries and matches being suspended. In 2020 Barcelona’s total revenue fell by 14% to 729 million euros. Throughout 2018-2020 the club reported a net loss of more than 430 million euros (Jakeman, 2024). While it is tough to pinpoint the moment that FC Barcelona’s decisions landed them in debt, Neymar Jr departure from the club could be named as the most agreeable moment. The Brazilian superstar was sold for a record breaking fee of 222 million euros to PSG. Barca tried replacing Neymar with two players (Philippe Coutinho and Ousmane Dembélé) for an expensive amount of 135 million euro each and failed to live up to the expectations. Coutinho was released three and a half years later for just 20 million euros and Dembélé was sold for a loss of 85 million to PSG. Barcelona’s wage bill increased significantly when Antonie Griezmann arrived for 120 million euros, the Frenchman lived up to be an unsuccessful addition and was sold to Atlético Madrid for 20 million euros (Transfermarkt, 2024).

During the summers of 2019 and 2022, Barcelona’s debt increased from 217 million euros to more than 1.3 billion euros, most of the debt as much as 60% was considered short-term loans. Much of these loans seems to have accumulated due to the redevelopment of Barcelona’s grounds and to finance high-profile transfers. Goldman Sachs have loaned more than 815 million to the club. From 2012 to 2022, Barcelona have spent 1.63 billion euros on players, which when calculated on a net basis led to a loss of 650 million euros. In comparison, Real Madrid over the same period have spent 1.16 billion euros and a spend of just 179 million euros. Simultaneously, it was expensive for the club to retain Lionel Messi, because his last four-year contract was rumored to be worth 555 million euros. From 2016 to 2020, Barcelona’s salaries grew 61% approximately coming up to 350 million euros per year. To counter the two main issues of making the club more effective on the pitch and getting the club’s finances under control, Barcelona’s president Joan Laporta spent 168.9 million euros for player acquisition. To get the club’s finances under control, Laporta worked in four Levers. One Sixth Street purchased 10% of Barcelona’s La Liga rights for 25 years worth around 200 million euros. In Lever two Sixth Street purchased 15% of the club’s La Liga rights for 25 years for  around 300 million euros. In Lever three the Socios purchased 24.5% of Barca studios for 100 million euros. And in Lever four Orpheus Media purchased 24.5% of Barca studios for 100 million (Gabriele,2022). In 2023 the club’s total income rose to 806 million euros coming close to their 2019 record of 852 million euros. A new kit deal with Nike worth around 120 million euros per year also helps increase revenue. To further increase income the club is renovating their iconic Camp Nou stadium and are hoping it will bring a major increase in matchday revenue (Jakeman, 2024).

Stadiums

When it comes to the topic of iconic stadiums, the two stadiums that cross every football fan’s mind are Real Madrid’s Santiago Bernabéu and FC Barcelona’s Camp Nou (Spotify camp Nou). Real Madrid’s Santiago Bernabéu has surpassed 350 million euros in income compared to the 150 million euros it generated pre-pandemic despite the stadium’s renovations still underway. The club hopes to increase the revenues generated by the iconic stadium by tapping into its fullest potential. The club’s financial forecasts predict an income of 400 million euros annually from the stadium alone. 

One of the major reasons for this surge in income ss the introduction of more VIP sections. These sections for their fans and guests have generated higher income per seat than that of regular seating. The club creates a one-of-a-kind and exceptional experience for their customers. The club also plans to host events year-round in the stadium hoping to host events ranging from games to concerts and corporate gatherings. Real Madrid have also collaborated with entities like Legends to further optimize the stadium’s revenue potential. The addition of restaurants and paid parking areas will also increase the club’s revenue. The club also plans to host sports games beyond football with the NFL’s opening game being played in the Santiago Bernabéu in 2025 and they further hope to host future NBA games at the stadium (Kowalski, 2023).

On the other hand, FC Barcelona’s Camp Nou has been estimated to finish renovations and be fully functional by the end of 2025-26 season. The club hopes to reach 85 million euros by the first of June 2025. The club is confident that they will surpass expectations of exceeding 340 million euros by the 2025-26 season. The predicted income from different activities at stadium predicted by the club are approximately 80 million euros from museum tours, approximately 74 million euros from ticketing, approximately 77 million euros from hospitality boxes VIP, approximately 50.2 million euros from season tickets, 47.2 million euros from sponsors, 8.5 million euros from meetings and events, 8.1 million euros from food and drinks, 2.2 million euros from parking per season (Frieros, 2023). 

Relevance for La Liga

La Liga has replaced the English Premier League (EPL) as Europe’s best league, with two out of three of the richest football clubs in the world located in Spain. Both Real Madrid and FC Barcelona compete with each other to sign the biggest and the best players in the world. In 2013, Real Madrid signed Gareth bale, Isco and Asher Illarramendi for 100 million euros while Brazilian superstar Neymar Jr signed with FC Barcelona for 50 million euros, where he had an incredible run with the Catalans (Marsden, 2013). La Liga also hosts two of the best players in the world in Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi who together combined have won 13 Ballon d’ors combined.In fact since 2000 16 Ballon d’ors have been won by players in La Liga, and the award returned to the English Premier League after 16 years having won by Rodri of Manchester City. Real Marid and FC Barcelona combined have won 20 champions league, they have also won 8 of the 20 FIFA club World Cup.

Real Madrid affects La Liga in various ways. They are one of the most money-making clubs in football is Real Madrid, who rakes in above €700 million in annual revenue lately. This brings them quite a lot for the pocket as they bring in many ticket sales and merchandise into their books, including broadcasting rights. They come with significant sponsorship and develop the economic balance of La Liga. For instance in 2020 they accounted for 18% of La Liga’s total revenue (Bridge, Dhillon, Tantam, 2022). Real Madrid’s popularity and exposure also boosted and increased La Liga’s appeal for broadcasters, contributing to a broadcasting revenue pool that exceeds 2 billion euros annually. It is estimated that La Liga would garner around €1.9 billion from broadcasting rights for the 2021-2022 season. Such an amount would have been severely impacted by the matches of Real Madrid. Super matches are now able to bring in bigger sums of TV rights. 

Consequently, even lesser clubs will have to harvest since top clubs like Real Madrid are sure to exert a majority of the league’s domestic and international rights deals (European club association reports, 2022). Real Madrid plays a key role in promoting La Liga, which boasts an estimated global fanbase of over 450 million. This vast audience boosts the league’s visibility and draws in international supporters, resulting in higher revenue from merchandise sales. For example, in recent years, Real Madrid’s merchandise sales exceeded €100 million, making a substantial contribution to La Liga’s overall commercial income (UEFA, FIFA 2021). La Liga’s reputation gets a lift as their player wage bill surpasses €300 million. For the 2022-2023 season, the club’s wage bill reached almost €353 million. This amount is among the highest globally, enabling the team to draw in top talent and enhance the overall quality of the league. Additionally, the club’s focus on youth development plays a significant role in its international standing (transfermarkt, 2023).

 FC Barcelona happens to be one of the most cash-rich football clubs on earth.In recent seasons, their revenues have even exceeded €700 million. All these factors directly or indirectly impact the overall revenues of La Liga through tickets sold, merchandising, and broadcasting rights. Barcelona contributed to a large percentage of the total revenue in La Liga’s 2021 numbers, ensuring stability in the league’s economy (Deloitte Sports Business Group, 2022). Barcelona’s popularity makes the league more attractive to broadcasters, whose revenue from broadcast exceeds €2 billion annually. This highly publicized match interest leads to more television revenue. Higher television rights contracts could favor all teams from this league (European Club Association, 2021). Because Barcelona has a record of achieving several La Liga titles throughout its history, its successes influence the overall league competitiveness. 

That success creates imbalances which influence competition; first, they have the ability to attract more significant sponsorships and investments so that supremacy just keeps snowballing (Szymanski, 2019). Being among the most known football teams worldwide, FC Barcelona makes La Liga known globally. Having subscribed by more than 300 million fans, their cross-border tours as well as a media presence boosts the prominence of the league and provides more international subscriptions and sponsors (Koller, 2020). Barcelona invested much money and time in its youth departments, especially via the prominent La Masia academy-which makes the league synonymous with developing skills. At the same time, as major player wage earners and sharp strategic investors, the club maintains the best in the fields, which propels its league’s collective level (Drayer, 2021).

Conclusion

The comparative study of Real Madrid and FC Barcelona highlights the impact of fan engagement on the business success and asset management of these two elite football clubs. On one hand, both the clubs share a similar level of on-field success and global recognition and brand value, and on the other, their approaches and practices to managing assets and fan loyalty are very different. Real Madrid’s emphasis on global brand expansion and diversifying their revenue streams, teamed with their effective use of media rights and merchandising has enabled the club to maximize its fan base as a key driver of financial success. In contrast, FC Barcelona has a more community-focused model of fan engagement which fosters deeper, regional fan loyalty, in turn determining their approach to brand management and long term asset optimisation. This difference underscores the different ways in which fan engagement can shape not only the revenue models but also the broader business strategies of leading sports organizations.

The rivalry between Real Madrid and FC Barcelona extends beyond the exciting stands of a football field, both clubs compete fiercely in terms of business strategy, financial performance, and fan loyalty. Real Madrid has built on their global reach, prioritizing revenue diversification through sponsorships, commercial partnerships, and strong digital presence. Whereas contrary to their rivals FC Barcelona have maintained a business model centered around community based fan engagement, emphasizing its deep historical ties to Catalonia and a membership-driven structure that fosters long-term loyalty. This rivalry highlights each club’s different and unique approach to asset management,marketing, and how fan relations directly influences their financial sustainability and competitive positioning. Conclusively, the clash between the two football giants reveals the growing significance of strategic business decisions in the modern sports industry,where fan loyalty and operational efficiency play a pivotal role in driving success both on and off the field. 

References

Callejo, M. B., & Forcadell, F. J. (2006). Real Madrid football club: A new model of business organization for sports clubs in Spain. Global Business and Organizational Excellence, 26(1), 51-64.

Larsen, R. (2024). The Business Model and Revenue Streams of Madrid Explained. Retrieved from: https://www.untaylored.com/post/the-business-model-and-revenue-streams-of-real-madrid-explained 

Pu, H., & James, J. (2017). The distant fan segment: Exploring motives and psychological connection of International National Basketball Association fans. International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 18(4), 418-438.

Somoggi (2019,December 17). Real Madrid and Barcelona economic impact.SportsValue.  Retrieved  from https://www.sportsvalue.com.br/en/real-madrid-and-barcelona-economic-impact/

Gifford . (2024,December 5). Real Madrid. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/topic/Real-Madrid

Gifford (2024,December 5 ). FC Barcelona. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved from https://www.britannica.com/topic/FC-Barcelona

Bonn  (2022,August 10). Real Madrid: Florentino Pérez y the socios of Los Blancos. Sporting News. Retrieved from https://www.sportingnews.com/in/football/news/real-madrid-florentino-perez-socios-los-blancos/zrv8nwkjorh4n5w9w8jngugy

Pettigrove (2015,August 4). Explaining the structure of Barcelona: The club’s working, youth, and La Masia board. Sportskeeda. Retrieved from https://www.sportskeeda.com/football/explaining-structure-barcelona-club-working-youth-la-masia-board

Kowalski (2023, June 28). Spain: Sky-high profits from the new Bernabéu. StadiumDB. Retrieved from https://stadiumdb.com/news/2023/06/spain_skyhigh_profits_from_the_new_bernabeu

Frieros (2023, September 10) Sport.Breakdown of Barca’s stadium income: Aiming for bigger profits. Sport. Retrieved from https://www.sport.es/en/news/barca/breakdown-barca-stadium-income-aiming-91927989

UEFA. (2022). UEFA annual report 2021/22. UEFA. Retrieved from https://editorial.uefa.com/resources/027e-175fe9b18b8d-59b8b4264404-1000/uefa_annual_report_2021-22.pdf

Deloitte. (2024). Annual review of football finance 2024. Deloitte. Retrieved from https://www.deloitte.com/global/en/Industries/tmt/research/gx-annual-review-of-football-finance.html

Marsden . (2013, September 10). La Liga: Why the Spanish league has taken the lead as the world’s best. Bleacher Report. Retrieved from https://bleacherreport.com/articles/1767737-la-liga-why-the-spanish-league-has-taken-lead-as-worlds-best

Dunn, R. (2023, February 2). Real Madrid and La Fábrica: Spain’s football factory. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/4142743/2023/02/02/real-madrid-la-fabrica-spain/

Wiltse (2020, September 16). The case for justifying La Fábrica as Real Madrid’s cash cow. Managing Madrid. Retrieved from https://www.managingmadrid.com/2020/9/16/21439716/the-case-for-justifying-la-fabrica-as-real-madrids-cash-cow

De Juan  (2023, November 23). Real Madrid’s La Fábrica academy produces more than Barcelona’s La Masia academy. AS. Retrieved from https://en.as.com/soccer/real-madrids-la-fabrica-academy-producing-more-than-barcelonas-la-masia-academy-n/

Kelly  (2023,October 11). What is La Masia? Barcelona’s famous youth academy and the star players it has produced. Goal. Retrieved from https://www.goal.com/en-in/news/what-is-la-masia-barcelonas-famous-youth-academy-star-players-produced/or0mpbswqb671voxzkzpt67j2

Robertson (2024, January 31). Barcelona: Huge debt, terrible transfer record, and Xavi leaving – what’s gone wrong? Transfermarkt. Retrieved from https://www.transfermarkt.com/barcelona-huge-debt-terrible-transfer-record-and-xavi-leaving-whats-went-wrong-/view/news/433210

Gabriele  (2022,August 28). Barcelona. Generalist. Retrieved from https://www.generalist.com/briefing/barcelona

Jakeman (2024,September 29) FC Barcelona emerging from the financial crisis. Front Office Sports. Retrieved from https://frontofficesports.com/fc-barcelona-emerging-from-financial-crisis/#:~:text=Throughout%202018%2C%202019%2C%20and%202020,of%20the%20club’s%20wage%20structure.

Kelly (2023,March 19) What is a Galáctico? Ronaldo, Beckham, and all of Real Madrid’s super signings. Goal. Retrieved from https://www.goal.com/en-in/news/what-galactico-ronaldo-beckham-all-real-madrids-super-signings/1lrrb6x9j0n9f1actzefqw47am

Attacking football  (2024,November 12)La Masia: The rise, fall, and revival of Barcelona’s famed youth academy. Yahoo Sports. Retrieved from https://sports.yahoo.com/la-masia-rise-fall-revival-023400844.html

Garcia (2024,July 24) .Real Madrid first club to reach $1bn in revenue, report says. ESPN. Retrieved from https://www.espn.in/football/story/_/id/40629331/real-madrid-first-club-world-report-1bn-revenue

Leveridge, S. (2024, February 1). Real Madrid to announce $757 million sponsorship deal with HP, reports. Forbes. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/samleveridge/2024/02/01/real-madrid-to-announce-757-million-sponsorship-deal-with-hp-as-reports/

Sim (2023, October 23). Barcelona’s 2023-24 budget: Income, loss, and Joan Laporta’s strategy. SportsPro Media. Retrieved from https://www.sportspromedia.com/news/barcelona-budget-2023-24-season-income-loss-joan-laporta/

Dalleres (2021,September 9) Barcelona suffered another financial blow with Rakuten set to pull the plug on €30m-a-year shirt sponsorship. City A.M. Retrieved from https://www.cityam.com/barcelona-suffer-another-financial-blow-with-rakuten-set-to-pull-plug-on-e30m-a-year-shirt-sponsorship/

Ed Dixon (2022, March 30). Barcelona’s Spotify sponsor: Shirt, Camp Nou stadium, and the Daniel Ek-Joan Laporta saga. SportsPro. Retrieved from https://www.sportspro.com/insights/analysis/barcelona-spotify-sponsor-shirt-camp-nou-stadium-daniel-ek-joan-laporta-worth/

TRT World. (2020,). Real Madrid generates biggest income in COVID-hit season. TRT World. Retrieved from https://www.trtworld.com/sport/real-madrid-generate-biggest-income-in-covid-hit-season-43141

Football Benchmark. (2023,February 23). Financial El Clásico: The rivalry between Real Madrid and Barcelona. Football Benchmark. Retrieved from https://www.footballbenchmark.com/library/financial_el_clasico

---